A Sinister Fattening: Dissecting the Tales of Pig Butchering and Other Cryptocurrency Scams
Ordekian, Marilyne ; Papasavva, Antonis ; Mariconti, Enrico ; Vasek, Marie (2024) — 2024 APWG Symposium on Electronic Crime Research (eCrime)
Type:
Proceedings Article
Country:
United Kingdom
Synopsis (AI-Generated)
The researchers analyzed 143 cryptocurrency-scam incidents from 133 consumer complaint narratives in California's DFPI Crypto Scam Tracker, collected in January 2024. Three authors used concept-driven thematic analysis and a 19-theme codebook, adapting scam-lure principles after coding 20 narratives. Scammers commonly ended communication on messaging applications regardless of their initial contact channel. Scammers used up to three applications during a scam and typically redirected victims to another application after establishing trust. The tracker consists of consumer complaints summarized by the California DFPI, and the DFPI does not verify victims' reported losses.
Identified Gaps (AI-Generated)
The paper identifies a need for standardized, publicly available complaint narratives across jurisdictions and for stronger mechanisms to receive and act on them. It also indicates that off-chain, fiat-linked cryptocurrency fraud is difficult to measure, and that data focused on successful complaints limits understanding of failed attempts. More evidence is needed on complex scams spanning diverse messaging platforms, their taxonomy, and offender modus operandi.
Methods (AI-Generated)
The researchers analyzed 143 cryptocurrency-scam incidents from 133 consumer complaint narratives in California’s DFPI Crypto Scam Tracker, collected in January 2024. Three authors used concept-driven thematic analysis and a 19-theme codebook, adapting scam-lure principles after coding 20 narratives. They coded scam types, personas, communication platforms, and monetary losses; estimated ranges for vague loss reports through coder consensus; and applied descriptive analysis, scam-type co-occurrence analysis, Markov-chain platform-transition modeling, cumulative distributions, and two-sample KS tests.
Limitations (AI-Generated)
The tracker consists of consumer complaints summarized by the California DFPI, and the DFPI does not verify victims’ reported losses. Monetary-loss data were absent in 19 cases and vague in 34 cases, requiring estimated ranges. Documentation inconsistencies required researchers to decide whether reports represented separate incidents. The dataset is inherently skewed toward successful scams, with only seven unsuccessful attempts, limiting conclusions about unsuccessful or interrupted fraud.
Future Work (AI-Generated)
Develop better mechanisms for receiving and acting on scam complaint narratives. Encourage organizations worldwide to publish case narratives and standardize reporting to enable pattern identification. Use deeper narrative analysis to refine scam taxonomies, understand offenders’ modus operandi, and develop identification methods. Conduct more research on narratives because direct collection from criminal advertisements is less effective for complex, multi-platform scams.
AI-Generated Content Notice
The synopsis and research notes on this page were generated with AI from available publication information and, when available, the uploaded paper text. They may contain errors, omissions, or interpretation issues. Readers should follow the DOI or source link, review the original publication, and make their own judgment about the content.
Found a possible error? Request a correction.